James Denselow: Haunted by the Soviet Afghan Legacy

James Denselow: Haunted by the Soviet Afghan Legacy HPFB.init();
HuffPost's QuickRead... ShareBox.ad = function (tag_id){if ($(tag_id) == undefined) return; if ($(tag_id).innerHTML != '') return;ad_spec = {"zone_info": "huffpost.politics/blog;politics=1;nickname=james-denselow;entry_id=791465;afghanistan=1;afghanistan-war=1;soviet-union=1;united-states=1;us-army=1","ord": 1291375262,"tile": 3,"width": 300,"height": 250,"el_id": tag_id + "_js","class_name": "ad_block ad_wide top","type": "iframe"}HuffPoUtil.WEDGJE.write(ad_spec, tag_id);};Loading... HuffPost's QuickRead... Loading... BIG NEWS:Deficit Commission|Mitt Romney|Pollster|Rielle Hunter| Smarter Ideas| More... | LogoutLog In| Sign Up  The Huffington Post December 3, 2010 REPORTERS 2012 ELECTIONS POLLSTER FUNDRACE HUFFPOST HILL EYES & EARS Front PagePoliticsMediaEntertainmentSportsComedyBusiness Tech N.Y. LivingGreenTravel More Divorce Health Style Food World College Impact Books Arts Religion LA Chicago Denver Video Blogs #ad_curtain {height:auto;margin:10px auto 0;width:938px}


James DenselowWriter on Middle East geopolitical and security issues

Posted: December 3, 2010 05:28 AMBIOBecome a FanGet Email AlertsBloggers' IndexHaunted by the Soviet Afghan Legacy What's Your Reaction: HPConfig.entry_digg_promo_url = 'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/james-denselow/haunted-by-the-soviet-afg_b_791465.html';digg facebook Twitter stumble redditdel.ico.us Important
Funny
Typical
Scary
Outrageous
Amazing
Innovative
Finally
Read More:Afghanistan, Afghanistan War, Soviet Union, United States, US Army, Politics News
Get Politics AlertsEmailComments

The US-led occupation of Afghanistan now outlasts the Soviet presence in the country, with recent tactical changes providing worrying parallels

The revelations of Wikileaks diplomatic cables will absorb headlines and historians for some time; however there is a danger in our attention being too focused on US views of the past rather than the worrying direction of the Afghan conflict in the present.

The narrative of Obama's Afghan strategy is being increasingly muddled by a gap between its rhetoric and its reality. The rhetoric was that a surge of troops combined with the effective use of the new counterinsurgency tactics would win hearts and minds and connect the Afghan state to its violent hinterland. The reality is that General McChrystal always struggled to turn the US military into an army of solider monks. Indeed this week a US Army medic pleaded guilty to being a member of a 12 man 'kill team' that killed Afghan civilians at random and collected their fingers as trophies. An inability to change the character of the occupying force has combined with the massive levels of corruption and an absence of real legitimacy within the government in Kabul, making it impossible to gain effective sovereignty over the country.

The 2014 deadline for leaving the country is likely to slip with Obama warning that "it is hard to anticipate exactly what is going to be necessary to keep the American people safe as of 2014". Despite NATO's senior civilian representative Mark Sedwill claiming that Kabul was safer than London, in November the Pentagon announced that violence in the country was at an all time high, with the numbers of clashes having increased fourfold since 2007.

Greater rates of violence are the consequence of continued failure, and US adjustments to such violence are increasingly showing parallels to Soviet tactics. Interestingly a year ago NATO approached Russia for assistance in Afghanistan, an approach which has now developed into Russian support training the Afghan army and the possible provision of attack helicopters. The US originally avoided the use of tanks in Afghanistan precisely to avoid comparisons to the Soviet occupation, however last month it was announced that main battle tanks were being deployed to Helmand, although according to a US Colonel they won't be used to 'oppress' the Afghans.

As the US passes the milestone of outlasting the Soviet occupation of the country their counterinsurgency strategy is at great peril of ignoring the failures of the Soviet experience. The return of the Russian helicopters and the introduction of US tanks is simply the latest reminder of the slippage in policy as Obama's rhetoric has crashed against the immovable shores of the Afghan reality.

 

Follow James Denselow on Twitter:www.twitter.com/JamesDenselow

Afghanistan More in Politics...
Former Bush Official Nicolle Wallace: Sarah Palin...Bush Tax Cuts: Fears Mount Of White...Jeb Bush Sides With His Mother On...Jim Inhofe Is Latest Casualty In 'War...   Comments 0 Pending Comments 0 View FAQ Login or connect with: More Login OptionsLogin with: Google Account Huffpost Account Yahoo AccountYou must be logged in to comment.Post CommentPreview CommentTo reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.

Share your Comment:

Post to Facebook.Post to Blogger.Post to Twitter.Post to WordPress.Post to TypePad.Post to Tumblr.Post to Yahoo! View All Recency  |  Popularity     New comments on this entry — Click to refreshLoading comments… Loading twitter module... Most Popular on HuffPostarUQk3uFTMEN0li%2Fp4faqn9M6jCyAfD6MunEegTxqfM37f9zxOWVUaA7fHM5WTRp2Scz1Gz7zKL2h9VmQAz9aQ%3D%3DD8%2FOnrkORBrxvPKECj0CbSOD003R4KmevmxFsD5rYwBk5gJOQWRbAehK0H2LrSScsUK26wSE4MiiUsuDoI3NeQ%3D%3D1 of 2 NASA Discovers New Life: Arsenic Bacteria With DNA Completely Alien To What We Know
5,888 Comments WATCH: Brooke Hogan Dons Bikini, Shares Workout Tips
302 Comments WATCH: The Best Epic FAILS Of November
511 Comments NEW POEM: Rebecca Linderberg's Beauty
76 Comments Howard Fineman Obama's Naivete on Bipartisanship Has...
1,946 Comments Kalle Bergman Swedish Hasselback Potatoes: The Comeback
278 Comments Joe Scarborough Urges GOP To 'Man Up' Against Sarah Palin
3,336 Comments WikiLeaks Cablegate LIVE Updates
6,720 Comments Johnny Depp: Disney Hated My 'Gay' Captain Sparrow
1,115 Comments HuffPost Reportersm%2FPNa0%2BlqLTEI2X1B7tYzu4o%2F0K3bKy60hhZZMwYXrPUNvlg3dlFuRaGDgGji%2BrY1 of 2 Mark Blumenthal: Swing And A Miss: McCain's Misguided Attack...
693 Comments Dan Froomkin: An Example Of How Civil Political Discourse...
528 Comments Marcus Baram: Dozens Of Major Military Contractors Granted Legal...
2,242 Comments Don't Miss HuffPost Bloggers1 of 5Sen. Bernie Sanders A Real Jaw Dropper at the Federal ReserveEdward Norton Making Charity Fun and Addictive for the HolidaysSen. Dianne Feinstein We Don’t Need BPA to Make a Baby BottleTed Danson A Return to Common Sense for Our CoastsJulius Genachowski Preserving a Free and Open InternetDavid Cameron World Cup 2018: Let’s Bring It to EnglandSec. Hilda Solis Time to Make This DREAM a RealitySen. Harry Reid Food Safety Modernization Act: Why Its Passage MattersAshley Judd Costs of ConvenienceJamie Lee Curtis Attitude of GratitudeHot Trends sarah palin unemployment extension unemployment extension 2010 wikileaks willow palin  .times_ticker { background-color:#E1E1E1; border:10px solid #E1E1E1; font-family:Arial,"Helvetica Neue",Helvetica,sans-serif; font-weight:bold; margin:10px 0;}.times_ticker_content {padding:0px 10px 0 10px;background-color:#FFFFFF;}.times_ticker_bottom {padding:0px 10px 0 10px;background-color:#FFFFFF;font-family:Arial;font-size:10px;font-weight:bold;fontcolor:#C1C1C1;text-align:right; height:5px; -moz-border-radius: 0px 0px 4px 4px; -webkit-border-radius: 0px 0px 4px 4px; border-radius: 0px 0px 4px 4px;}.times_ticker_header { height:35px; background:#FFFFFF url(/images/module_bg_border.png) repeat scroll 0px 0px; -moz-border-radius: 4px 4px 0px 0px; -webkit-border-radius: 4px 4px 0px 0px; border-radius: 4px 4px 0px 0px;}.times_ticker_header_text {padding-top:10px;text-align:center;}.times_ticket_container{border-color:#CCC;border-width:1px;border-style:solid none none none;}.times_ticker_image { float:left; padding:10px 13px 10px 0px;}.times_ticker_text {padding:10px 10px 10px 0px;border:1px solid red';}.times_ticker_title {font-family:Arial;font-size:15px;font-weight:bold;color:black';}.times_ticker_readmore {font-family:Arial;font-size:12px;font-weight:bold;color:#093b72;}.times_ticker_title{font-weight:bold;color:black;} Quotes: New York Governor David Paterson on His Job StressHulu To Launch International ServiceThree-Year-Old Boy Saves Endangered Sea Turtle. What Did You Do Today? TOP VIDEO PICKS1 of 8 Embattled Congressman censured "Middle class" tax cut gets House ok Obama knocks FIFA over World Cup var ndn_max_page = 8;var ndn_entries = [[{'title':'Embattled Congressman censured', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23215066&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23215066.jpg'},{'title':'"Middle class" tax cut gets House ok', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23215043&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23215043.jpg'},{'title':'Obama knocks FIFA over World Cup', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23215022&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23215022.jpg'}],[{'title':'Pentagon backs gay ban repeal.', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23215004&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23215004.jpg'},{'title':'DeMint: "We Need to Extend Tax Cuts"', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23214967&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23214967.jpg'},{'title':'World leaders condemn Wikileaks', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23214966&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23214966.jpg'}],[{'title':'Tax Cut Showdown', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23214962&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23214962.jpg'},{'title':'Bristol Palin's Dad on DWTS?', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23214927&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23214927.jpg'},{'title':'Turning up the heat on China', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23214923&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23214923.jpg'}],[{'title':'Deficit Panel Recommends $3.9T in Cuts', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23214912&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23214912.jpg'},{'title':'Jimmy Carter: Ted Kennedy Blocked Health Care Reform', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23214900&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23214900.jpg'},{'title':'Obama and GOP: Revival or Survival', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23214892&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23214892.jpg'}],[{'title':'Wikileaks Fallout: Clinton Repairs Relations', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23214816&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23214816.jpg'},{'title':'Robert Gibbs on White House Summit', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23214800&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23214800.jpg'},{'title':'Senate GOP Pledges to Block Everything', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23214801&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23214801.jpg'}],[{'title':'Senate Passes Food Safety Overhaul', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23213078&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23213078.jpg'},{'title':'GOP Has "Very Nice" Meeting with Obama', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23213079&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23213079.jpg'},{'title':'US: China has duty to push NKorea', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23213074&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23213074.jpg'}],[{'title':'McCain: Senate "Much Poorer Place" Without Feingold', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23213059&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23213059.jpg'},{'title':'Obama, Republicans talk taxes', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23213058&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23213058.jpg'},{'title':'Obama Extends Olive Branch to GOP', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23213040&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23213040.jpg'}],[{'title':'Jimmy Carter's Advice for President Obama', 'entry_url':'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/newsinc/landing_page.html?vid=23213047&cid=993&freewheel=90057&sitesection=huffingtonpost_pol', 'img_url':'http://thumbnail.newsinc.com/23213047.jpg'}]];var ndn_pagination = new CommonPaginator({'moduleName': 'ndn', 'maxPage': ndn_max_page, 'is_circle': true, 'is_custom_data': true, 'custom_data': ndn_entries, 'custom_img_width': 74, 'custom_img_height': 54, 'custom_play_button': true});HuffPoUtil.ImageLoader.foldCheck("hp_ndn_page_1"); Follow Huffington Post MOST DISCUSSED RIGHT NOW Fears Mount Of White House Cave On Tax Cuts
14,318 Comments Sarah Palin Caught Off Guard By The Press
178 Comments HOT ON FACEBOOK WATCH: Defense Secretary Warns GOP Senators They're Going Down A 'Dangerous Path' On DADT
457 Comments SWING AND A MISS: McCain's Misguided Attack On 'Don't Ask, Don't Tell' Survey
691 Comments HOT ON TWITTER Sarge, There's a Naked Gay Guy in the Shower!
42 Comments Social Security Cuts Are Part Of Deficit Plan
654 Comments HUFFPOST'S BIG NEWS PAGES Sarah Palin Blindsided By Mainstream Press & Mitt Romney's JabMitt Romney Michele Bachmann's Fundraising Totaled $13.2 MillionMichele Bachmann David Brooks Reveals His Problem With RepublicansVideo John Ensign Could Face Major Challenges In 2012John Ensign Andy Stern Will Vote No On Deficit CommissionDeficit Commission WikiLeaks RETURNS: Website Takes New Approach After Being Forced OfflineWikileaks LeBron James Returns To Cleveland: Heat Star Scores Season-High Against Former Team (PHOTOS/VIDEOS)NBA Van Used By Children's Charity Torched Before Holiday MissionChristmas Congress Clears Stopgap Spending Bill, Avoids Government Shutdown For Two More WeeksGovernment Shutdownmore big news pages »  
Front PagePoliticsBusinessMediaEntertainmentComedySportsStyleWorldGreen Food TravelTech Living Health Divorce Arts Books Religion Impact Education College NY LA Chicago Denver BlogsAdvertise | Make HuffPost your Home Page | RSS | Careers | FAQ | Contact UsCopyright © 2010 HuffingtonPost.com, Inc. | User Agreement | Privacy | Comment Policy | About Us | Powered by Movable Type

HuffPost Lightbox